HoneyDew Scrumptious vs Cushion Lab Deep Sleep Pillow
Compared from manufacturer specifications and our research — neither pillow has been hands-on tested yet · See how Mr. Squish tests pillows
HoneyDew Scrumptious Side Pillow
HoneyDew Sleep · Shredded Memory Foam · Medium
A tall shredded copper-infused foam pillow with a scooped shoulder cut-out and a removable, adjustable fill bag. Plush on contact, surprisingly supportive underneath.
8.9/10 · from $130
Read the full review
Cushion Lab Deep Sleep Pillow
Cushion Lab · Contour Memory Foam · Medium
A sculpted memory foam pillow designed by in-house ergonomists, with a contoured center for back sleeping and raised side bolsters for side sleeping, wrapped in a dual-layer washable cover.
8.8/10 · from $89
Read the full reviewThe HoneyDew Scrumptious Side Pillow and the Cushion Lab Deep Sleep Pillow are built on the same insight: a rectangular pillow wastes the space where a side sleeper's shoulder needs to go. Both use a curved, scooped shape with a shoulder notch, and both aim to keep the neck level while cradling the head.
Under the similar silhouettes, though, they are different constructions at different prices. The HoneyDew is a large, adjustable shredded-fill pillow you can tune. The Cushion Lab is a smaller, sculpted solid-foam pillow with dual-height contours that you take as it comes — for roughly $40 less.
Side by side
| HoneyDew Scrumptious Side Pillow | Cushion Lab Deep Sleep Pillow | |
|---|---|---|
| Fill | Shredded foam + fiber blend | Solid sculpted memory foam |
| Firmness | Medium, adjustable | Medium, fixed |
| Loft | Roughly 6–7 in as shipped, adjustable down | Scooped center with raised side bolsters |
| Adjustable | Yes — remove fill to tune | No — dual-height contour instead |
| Shape | Curved slab with shoulder notch | Scooped center, side bolsters, shoulder cut-outs |
| Positions | Side, back | Side, back |
| Trial | 60 nights | 30 nights |
| Warranty | 3 years | 1 year |
| Price | $130 | $89 |
Shape: one big curve vs sculpted zones
The HoneyDew is essentially a conventional pillow with the bottom corners curved away, so your shoulder tucks under instead of bunching the pillow up. It is physically large — a wide, lofty slab that ships deliberately overstuffed, and most people should pull out a handful or two of fill on the first night.
The Cushion Lab takes the idea further with molded zones: a scooped center for back sleeping, raised bolsters on the sides for side sleeping, and cut-outs for the shoulder in either position. It is more engineered, smaller, and lower-profile — but what you buy is exactly what you sleep on, with no way to change the height.
Fit: tuning vs hoping the geometry matches
Adjustability is the HoneyDew's core advantage. Shoulder width, mattress firmness, and head weight all change the loft you need, and being able to remove fill means the pillow adapts to you. Broad-shouldered side sleepers can keep it full; narrower frames can strip it down.
The Cushion Lab's dual-height design is a clever partial answer — flip between the center scoop and the side bolsters and you effectively get two lofts in one pillow. But if neither height matches your shoulder gap, there is no third option. It fits average frames best; very broad or very narrow shoulders should measure carefully before buying.
Feel: plush-tunable vs structured-cradling
The HoneyDew's shredded fill blend feels plush on the surface with support underneath — closer to a luxury hotel pillow that happens to hold its loft. The Cushion Lab's solid foam feels denser and more cradling; your head settles into the contour and the pillow does the positioning for you. Neither sleeps notably hot, though both are foam and neither is a true cooling pillow.
Value
The Cushion Lab undercuts the HoneyDew by about $40, and for an average-framed side sleeper whose shoulders match the contour heights, it delivers most of the benefit for less. The HoneyDew justifies its premium with adjustability, a 60-night trial instead of 30, and a 3-year warranty instead of 1 — a better bet when you are not certain the fixed geometry will fit.
Choose the HoneyDew Scrumptious Side Pillow if you want the curved shoulder-notch design with adjustable fill, have broader or narrower-than-average shoulders, or want the longer trial and warranty.
Ready to give it a squish?
Choose the Cushion Lab Deep Sleep Pillow if you have an average frame, switch between side and back sleeping, prefer the cradling feel of sculpted solid foam, and want to spend about $40 less.
Ready to give it a squish?
Our verdict
Both pillows execute the curved side-sleeper concept well. The Cushion Lab Deep Sleep Pillow is the better value for average-framed side-and-back sleepers whose shoulders fit its molded heights. The HoneyDew Scrumptious Side Pillow is the safer and more flexible choice overall — adjustability means it fits a wider range of bodies, and the longer trial and warranty reduce the risk of the higher price.