Coop Original vs Casper Original Pillow
Compared from product documentation, with named firsthand experience identified in the relevant review. No completed comparative sleep trial is recorded. · See how Mr. Squish tests pillows
Coop Home Goods Original
Coop Sleep Goods · Shredded Memory Foam · Medium
Choose it if: Choose the Coop Original if you sleep on your side, don't know your ideal loft, share a bed with someone of a different frame, or want a pillow you can keep tuning for years.
Main trade-off: You want a fixed contour or dislike handling loose foam.
Manufacturer specificationsListed from $89; check size and current offer
Read the full review
Casper Original Pillow
Casper · Down Alternative · Medium
Choose it if: Choose the Casper Original if you're a combination sleeper who wants a plush, low-maintenance pillow you can throw in the washing machine, and a medium loft already suits you.
Illustrative image; check the source for the exact product.
Manufacturer specificationsListed from $75; check size and current offer
Read the full reviewThese two are the most common shortlist in the whole pillow category, and they are almost opposites. The Coop Original is an adjustable shredded memory foam pillow you tune to your body. The Casper Original is a fixed down-alternative pillow-in-pillow that you take as it comes and wash in the machine.
The decision comes down to one question: do you know what loft you need? If you do not, adjustability is worth more than any other feature. If you do, and it happens to be a medium, the simpler pillow is easier to live with.
Side by side
| Coop Home Goods Original | Casper Original Pillow | |
|---|---|---|
| Fill | Cross-cut shredded memory foam + microfiber | Down alternative, inner and outer chamber |
| Firmness | Medium, tunable from soft to firm | Medium, fixed |
| Loft | Roughly 3–6 in, adjustable | Roughly 5 in, fixed |
| Adjustable | Yes — extra fill included | No |
| Machine washable | Whole pillow, machine washable | Whole pillow |
| Best positions | Side, back, combination | Combination, back, side |
| Cooling | Average | Average |
| Trial | 100 nights | 30 nights |
| Price | $89 | $75 |
Feel: dense and moldable vs light and plush
The Coop feels substantial. Shredded foam has weight and mass, it holds whatever shape you push it into, and it stays put under your head all night. Some people love that; others find it dead compared with a fibre pillow.
The Casper is the opposite — light, springy, and hotel-like. The outer chamber is soft on contact and the inner chamber stops it from bottoming out, so it feels plush without being a pancake. It does need a daily fluff.
Support by sleep position
For side sleepers the Coop wins outright. At full fill it holds the tall loft a side sleeper needs, and the fact that you can dial it means broad and narrow shoulders both get served by the same purchase.
For combination sleepers the Casper closes the gap. It reshapes instantly as you roll, where shredded foam has to be nudged back into place. Back sleepers can be happy on either, though the Coop needs about a third of the fill removed first.
Stomach sleepers should take the Coop, stripped well down — the Casper's fixed loft is low but not low enough for everyone.
Heat, upkeep and durability
Neither is a cooling pillow. The Coop holds heat under the head over a full night; the Casper breathes a little better but its fibre fill traps warmth too. Hot sleepers should look at a latex or ventilated option instead.
Coop documents a washable pillow and cover, so it is incorrect to assume every foam pillow is spot-clean only. Follow each model’s care label, and allow the fill to dry fully. We have not measured a durability winner between these pillows.
Value
The Casper is cheaper up front and the Coop is cheaper over time, because refill fill costs a few dollars and rescues a pillow that would otherwise be finished. The Coop's 100-night trial is also considerably more useful than 30 nights when it takes two weeks just to settle on a fill level.
Before you choose either pillow
- Match the listed model, size, and height to the item in your cart. Similar names can refer to different products.
- Check the height while lying on your own mattress. Advertised loft is not a measurement under your head.
- Read pillow-specific return terms, including opened-product eligibility, fees, and the seller’s policy.
- Check cover and inner-fill care separately. Cooling materials do not establish all-night cooling.
Mr. Squish may earn a commission from the following price links. This does not determine our recommendations. Prices vary by size, seller, and promotion.
Ready to give it a squish?
Ready to give it a squish?
Our verdict
The Coop Original is the better pillow for more people, mainly because adjustability removes the single biggest reason pillows fail. The Casper Original is the better pillow for anyone who wants plush, washable simplicity and already knows a medium loft works for them.
See the full shortlist
Best Pillows for Combination Sleepers
Compare these two pillows with the other leading research picks for this category.
View the best-of guide →Related best-of guides
Related pillow comparisons
Frequently asked questions
Which is better for side sleepers?
The Coop Original. Set to a high fill it holds the tall loft side sleeping needs, while the Casper's fixed medium loft is too low for most side sleepers.
Can you wash the Casper Original pillow?
Casper lists the Original as washable; check its exact care label. Coop also documents a washable Original pillow and cover, with its own washing and drying instructions.
Which runs cooler?
Neither is a cooling pillow. The Casper breathes slightly better; if heat is your main issue, look at a latex or ventilated foam pillow.
Which lasts longer?
The Coop. Shredded foam holds loft for years and replacement fill is cheap, whereas down alternative gradually mats down.