Every MyPillow Version, Compared
MyPillow's product line looks more complicated than it is. Every bed pillow in it uses the same core: shredded polyurethane foam, marketed as patented interlocking fill, made in Minnesota, machine washable and dryable, covered by a 10-year warranty and a 60-day money-back guarantee. What you are actually choosing between is the casing, whether there is a gusset, and how loft is selected. This guide lays out those differences using MyPillow's own product and fitting documentation, then tells you which series is worth the money. We have not slept on these pillows — this is a research comparison, not a hands-on test.
In this guide
The one thing that applies to every model
None of the MyPillow bed pillows are adjustable in the sense that Coop, Pillow Cube or Nest are. There is no zippered liner and no bag of spare fill. You pick a support level at checkout and live with it, or exchange it within the 60-day window.
That makes the fitting decision the most consequential part of buying a MyPillow, and it is the reason so many owner complaints read as 'too flat' or 'too tall' rather than 'badly made'.
MyPillow Classic — the cheap one
Same fill, plainer shell: a 100% cotton casing with a simple envelope build and no gusset, and no colour-piped loft system. It is the model most often sold at the deepest discount and the one you are most likely to find on a shelf.
Without the gusset the fill spreads more under load, so the Classic effectively sleeps lower than a Premium of similar thickness. That is fine for stomach sleepers, guest beds and CPAP users who want something squashable, and a poor match for broad-shouldered side sleepers.
- Best for: guest rooms, stomach sleepers, spare pillows
- Key feature: lowest price in the line, cotton casing
- Trade-off: least support, no loft-level system
MyPillow 2.0 — the cooling one
The 2.0 is MyPillow's newer series. According to MyPillow's own comparison documentation it keeps four support levels (lower loft, medium loft, more loft, most loft), uses an envelope seam with no gusset, and adds temperature-regulating technology built into the casing along with a softer exclusive fabric.
If your objection to the original MyPillow was heat, this is the version aimed at you: same fill, cooler shell. Because it drops the gusset, expect it to behave a little more like the Classic in terms of holding height, with the loft-level choice doing the work instead.
- Best for: hot sleepers who still want the MyPillow fill and warranty
- Key feature: temperature-regulating casing, four support levels
- Trade-off: envelope seam, no gusset
Giza series — the cotton upgrade
The Giza pillows use the same patented interlocking fill inside a casing made with Giza cotton, a long-staple Egyptian cotton that feels smoother and finer than standard cotton. MyPillow distinguishes loft on the Giza Premium with coloured piped cording rather than a colour label, and lists the Standard/Queen at 16.5" x 26" + 2" and the King at 16.5" x 32" + 2".
You are paying for the shell, not the support. If the reason you dislike cheap pillows is how the fabric feels against your face, Giza is the sensible pick; if your problem is neck pain or heat, it changes nothing.
- Best for: buyers who care about casing feel
- Key feature: Giza (long-staple Egyptian) cotton casing
- Trade-off: no support or cooling advantage over the Premium
Decoding the colour loft levels
MyPillow's fitting guide keys the levels to body frame and sleep position rather than a measured loft in inches:
- Yellow — lower loft: petite frames, stomach sleepers, people used to down or feather, children
- White — medium loft: most women in a medium to large shirt, men in a small to medium shirt
- Green — more loft: larger frames, and most side sleepers
- Blue — most loft: the broadest shoulders and the tallest loft requirement
- Between two levels? Order the taller one — a pillow can be compressed, but height cannot be added
Washing: the real advantage, and its cost
MyPillow's care documentation says the whole pillow — casing and fill together — goes in the washer and the dryer, and recommends laundering roughly every four months, or every two months with allergies. The 10-year warranty explicitly covers laundering. Almost no foam pillow can make that claim.
The catch is what washing does over time. Shredded foam clumps as it is agitated and heated, and clumped fill sleeps lumpier and lower. Dry it fully with dryer balls, break the clumps apart by hand while it is warm, and use a pillow protector so you can wash less often.
Which one should you actually buy?
If you want a MyPillow: the Premium at a promo price is the version that makes the most sense, because the gusset and the explicit loft levels are the only features in the line that affect support. The 2.0 is the pick for hot sleepers, Giza for fabric snobs, and Classic only as a spare or guest pillow.
If your real problem is neck or shoulder pain, none of these is the answer. A genuinely adjustable shredded-foam pillow or a cervical contour lets you tune or shape the support instead of gambling on a colour, and that is where our higher-scoring picks sit.
About the advertising
MyPillow's marketing has drawn regulatory and media scrutiny over health-related claims, and sleep-study statistics quoted in its listings should be read as promotional material rather than independent evidence. That has no bearing on whether the foam is comfortable — it is just a reminder to buy on construction, warranty and fit, the same way you would with any other brand.
Pillows we recommend for this
MyPillow Premium
Shoppers who want a cheap, washable, made-in-USA shredded foam pillow
FAQ
Keep reading
Get the Mr. Squish Pillow Cheat Sheet
A simple guide to choosing the right pillow based on your sleep position, body size, and comfort preferences.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Affiliate disclosure: Mr. Squish may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Recommendations come from hands-on testing. Learn more.