Brooklinen Pillow Reviews

Bedding-first, with strong pillowcase options

Brooklinen came up as a direct-to-consumer sheet company, and that heritage shows: the fabrics are the strongest part of the range. The down pillow is a solid plush option, but it is the mulberry silk pillowcase that most often earns a place in our roundups, where momme weight and finish quality matter more than any brand story.

These are research picks based on manufacturer specifications and our research, not hands-on testing. See how we test pillows

What Brooklinen does well

Excellent fabric quality across sheets, cases, and pillow shells
Reasonable pricing for the material grade, especially on silk
Frequent sales make the premium items genuinely good value

Watch-outs

Pillow range is narrower than dedicated pillow brands
Silk requires careful, cold, gentle laundering

Best for: Shoppers upgrading the fabric layer of their bed

Brooklinen pillow reviews

Browse every Brooklinen product currently in our catalog. Each review links back here so the whole brand line can be compared in context.

Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow

Best for Shoppers who want recycled synthetic fill with preset support choices

Recycled poly microgel fill in a cotton sateen shell, offered in Soft, Medium and Firm. The fill amount is not documented as user-adjustable.

Verified specs: Recycled poly microgel fill · medium feel · Most products within 365 days; eligibility conditions and $9.95 return fee apply trial.

Research pick — based on manufacturer specifications and our research.

Check Price Read Full Review

Brooklinen Down Pillow

Best for Down shoppers comparing current Soft, Medium and Firm support choices

Canadian down and a sateen shell, with preset support choices. Confirm the current version, composition label and laundering instructions before buying.

Verified specs: Canadian down; exact composition depends on selected label fill · medium feel.

Research pick — based on manufacturer specifications and our research.

Check Price Read Full Review

Brooklinen Marlow Pillow

Best for Combination sleepers who want three firmness settings in one pillow

Cooling-infused memory foam with side gusset zippers — open or close them to move between a plush and a firm feel without adding or removing any fill.

Verified specs: Cooling-infused memory foam blend fill · medium feel · adjustable fill · Brooklinen 365-day return policy trial.

Research pick — based on manufacturer specifications and our research.

Check Price Read Full Review

Brooklinen Mulberry Silk Pillowcase

Best for Value buyers who want real 22-momme silk under $60

The same 22-momme mulberry silk spec as the premium brands at a noticeably lower price, with an envelope closure and Brooklinen's bedding-grade quality control.

Verified specs: Mulberry Silk (22 momme) fill · soft feel.

Research pick — based on manufacturer specifications and our research.

Check Price Read Full Review

Brooklinen comparisons

Head-to-head pages involving Brooklinen, organized around construction, adjustability, sleep-position fit, and buying risk.

Head to headBrooklinen vs Parachute Down PillowTwo premium down pillows compared on fill power, density options, shell fabric, ethics certification and price. Head to headBrooklinen Marlow vs Snuggle-Pedic PillowBrooklinen Marlow Pillow and Snuggle-Pedic Ultra-Luxury Bamboo Pillow compared on construction, adjustability, sleep-position fit, and value using published product information. Head to headCoop Original vs Brooklinen Marlow PillowCoop Home Goods Original and Brooklinen Marlow Pillow compared on construction, adjustability, sleep-position fit, and value using published product information. Head to headBrooklinen Down vs Saatva Down Alternative PillowBrooklinen Down Pillow and Saatva Down Alternative Pillow compared on construction, adjustability, sleep-position fit, and value using published product information.

Guides related to Brooklinen

Use these guides to decide whether the brand's materials, loft, and design make sense for your sleep setup.

GuideAre Microfibre Pillows Any Good?Microfibre and polyester fill is the cheapest pillow material on the shelf. Here's honestly where it works, where it fails, and how long it lasts. GuideAre Wool Pillows Good? Pros, Cons and Who They SuitWool pillows regulate temperature and resist dust mites, but they are firm and they compress. Here's how wool compares to foam, down and latex. GuideBed Sheet Materials Compared: Cotton, Linen, Bamboo, Silk, MicrofibreHow percale, sateen, linen, bamboo viscose, silk, and microfibre actually differ in breathability, feel, durability, and care — and who each one suits. GuideHow Often Should You Wash Your Sheets?A realistic washing schedule for sheets, pillowcases, pillows, and protectors — plus the temperature and drying details that matter for allergies and acne. GuideHow to Wash a Silk Pillowcase Without Ruining ItUse the exact care label, then choose a permitted cold wash and gentle drying method. Includes current Blissy and Brooklinen examples. GuidePillowcase Materials Compared: Cotton, Bamboo, Silk, Linen, and PolyesterCotton percale, sateen, bamboo viscose, mulberry silk, linen, and microfiber — how each feels, how cool it sleeps, and which is worth the money for skin and hair.

Comparing brands? Start with our overall best pillows list or the pillow finder.

Affiliate disclosure: Mr. Squish may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Affiliate relationships never determine our recommendations — see how we test.